Guinness Reviews - Hartley's

Spillane

@velvetbrewery5317

3.9

Good pour but comes off a bit malty.

• 5Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 3.5Mouthfeel
• 3Taste

An Dorcha Ceann

@midnighthead1508

4.6

🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺

• 4.7Appearance
• 4.3Creaminess
• 4.7Mouthfeel
• 4.8Taste

Guinness Authority

@ak9820

4.4

solid pint. feels like a whole meal. really flavorful.

• 3.9Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.4Mouthfeel
• 4.7Taste

sam b

@smoothpub9121

5.0

Best Guinness in the city by far. Great staff.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Kira

@kirajc

5.0

imo this is the best bar in America hands down.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Robyn4Pints

@robyn4pints

4.6

An intensely good Guinness with a gorgeous pour. Right on the nose for creaminess, mouthfeel, and overall appearance. Hartley's does it well!!

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4.6Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Ben

@peacockstampede

4.5

Sensational pour and an even better pint. Will be back for the Guinness.

• 4.4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

Ndombele28

@ndombele28

4.7

Lovely pub, lovely staff. I wish I lived closer, I’d come here all the time.

• 4.8Appearance
• 4.6Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.7Taste

Alex Tironati

@livelycheers6189

4.6

a creamy delight that is lifting me to another level

• 4.6Appearance
• 4.9Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

G Unit

@biggeezy

4.4

Mightve got them on a bad day, this is a great guiness but not the best

• 5Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Logan

@logan_fitzy

4.9

Absolute creamer

• 4.8Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.8Taste

John O’Connor

@jcoconnor

4.9

Always an excellent pint. It's got to be the best in Brooklyn.

• 4.8Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4.9Mouthfeel
• 4.7Taste

noel smyth

@freshtap1808

4.0

Nice Guinness, great atmosphere. Definitely coming back

• 4Appearance
• 3Creaminess
• 3Mouthfeel
• 4Taste

Brendan

@bem135

4.9

The Best in Brooklyn!

• 5Appearance
• 4.7Creaminess
• 4.8Mouthfeel
• 5Taste