Guinness Reviews - Mary Margaret's Olde Irish Tavern
Read Guinness reviews with ratings and images for Mary Margaret's Olde Irish Tavern. Find out what people are saying about their Guinness experience.
Locations
Best Guinness on this side of Florida. I can't drink Guinness anywhere else because of how great theirs is. They have their own dedicated tap and treat it the way a proper Guinness should be treated.
5
Appearance
4.9
Creaminess
4.8
Mouthfeel
4.8
Taste
Solid creamer. St Pete rocks
4.5
Appearance
4
Creaminess
4
Mouthfeel
4.5
Taste

Good pub with top service
4
Appearance
4.2
Creaminess
4
Mouthfeel
4.2
Taste

Consistent good pours. Great taste. They ran out of Guinness glasses and were pouring in pint glasses. Had to ask and wait for a Guinness glass.
4.1
Appearance
4.2
Creaminess
4.5
Mouthfeel
4.5
Taste
Data last updated: January 10, 2026