Guinness Reviews - The Elgin
Read Guinness reviews with ratings and images for The Elgin. Find out what people are saying about their Guinness experience.
Explore more on our world map
Locations
Search for a location to read its Guinness reviews.
Proper pint in ny!
- 4.6Appearance
- 4.7Creaminess
- 4.8Mouthfeel
- 4.9Taste
Updated Sun July 12th, 2026
First review on the app. Absolute banger of a Guinness. Split the G to too.
- 4.8Appearance
- 4.7Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Mon January 19th, 2026
Nice pint, bit on the pricier side if you plan on slamming 12 like I did. Server was 5/10 however.
- 4.5Appearance
- 4.5Creaminess
- 4Mouthfeel
- 4.3Taste
Added Mon January 19th, 2026
Not the head I was looking for… but the head I needed. Great pint. Bartender with the mustache is a douche.
- 3.5Appearance
- 4.3Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.3Taste
Added Mon January 19th, 2026
Best pint in midtown hands down!
- 5Appearance
- 4.8Creaminess
- 4.8Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Mon November 17th, 2025
Excellent Pint of Guinness. It was so good. I was pleasantly surprised!
- 5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 4.2Mouthfeel
- 4.9Taste
Added Mon November 17th, 2025
Delicious & lovely location
- 5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 3.5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Sun November 9th, 2025
Old Style Tulip Glass - pouring a bit high the night I stopped in
- 4Appearance
- 3.5Creaminess
- 3Mouthfeel
- 3.5Taste
Added Fri July 4th, 2025