John O’Connor's Reviews
They have 2 reviews with an average rating of 4.75

Always an excellent pint. It's got to be the best in Brooklyn.
4.8
Appearance
5
Creaminess
4.9
Mouthfeel
4.7
Taste

I got this particular pint from the new bar as it looks like the place was recently remodeled. It was slightly too cold if I'm being hyper critical, but overall an excellent pint. I got one from the original bar after and the temperature was better.
4.4
Appearance
4.5
Creaminess
4.5
Mouthfeel
5
Taste