Guinness Reviews - P. McDaid’s Irish Pub
Read Guinness reviews with ratings and images for P. McDaid’s Irish Pub. Find out what people are saying about their Guinness experience.
Explore more on our world map
Locations
Search for a location to read its Guinness reviews.
4.0
The vibe in this place is not my style; a little midtowny, more restaurant than bar, but I must admit the Guinness was solid.
- 3.9Appearance
- 3.5Creaminess
- 4.1Mouthfeel
- 4.2Taste
Updated Mon September 22nd, 2025
4.1
A great pint just outside the tourist trap of Time Sq.
- 4.5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 4Mouthfeel
- 3.9Taste
Updated Wed October 1st, 2025
3.2
Nice looking pint, however poured very quickly, hence the watery mouthfeel - overall ok
- 3.5Appearance
- 3Creaminess
- 3Mouthfeel
- 3.2Taste
Added Sat August 30th, 2025
20 OZ Old Style Tulip Glass - Poured well - Good temperature - Very Solid Pint
- 4.2Appearance
- 4.2Creaminess
- 4.2Mouthfeel
- 4.2Taste
Added Mon July 28th, 2025