Guinness Reviews - Grace's

Melvin Doo

@melvindoo182

4.6

So so so good. One of my favorites. Late pic was too busy enjoying the pints

• 4.6Appearance
• 4.7Creaminess
• 4.6Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

Shtickler

@jdm

4.6

One of the best in NYC and in USA.

• 4.6Appearance
• 4.6Creaminess
• 4.6Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Emily

@egb

4.5

One of the best in nyc

• 4.4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

Montey’s Creamers

@montey

4.8

Perfection

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Guinness & Black

@guinnessandblack

4.9

A beautiful pub, attentive and well rounded staff behind the bar pouring a proper pint. Love the pint glasses.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Real G’s move in Silence

@cmacj97

4.4

One of the best pints in NYC. Unfortunately I went during one of the hottest days of the year and the door was open so the Guinness didn’t taste as chilled as it should.

• 4.6Appearance
• 4.2Creaminess
• 4.4Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

ChrispyPints

@chrispypint

3.9

good and creamy not the best glass

• 3.6Appearance
• 4.3Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 3.6Taste

G

@smoothhead3417

4.3

This thing has a 5 head but the glass was clean as fuck. Temp was on the warm side (don’t bother me) but still had a nice mouthfeel. Bitterness upfront but chills to chocolate. Overall solid pint.

• 4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.3Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Aldogs

@velvetkeg8878

4.4

Head was a bit large but still a great pint

• 3.5Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.7Mouthfeel
• 4.9Taste

El Jefe

@jzirotti

4.1

Nice Guinness. Head was a bit large. But had about 5 pints and they were all consistent.

• 4Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4.2Mouthfeel
• 4.2Taste

Jamie Kreamces

@jkream

4.9

one of the best in the city frfr

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

AtTheOnyxGates

@attheonyxgates

4.4

If you’re good to Grace’s, Grace’s will be good to you. A great aul boozer. A great aul pint. Irish pub simplicity at its finest. A Guinness near its best marks in the city.

• 4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

CREAMA finder

@uglytoots

4.6

Great creama, great setting.

• 4.4Appearance
• 4.6Creaminess
• 4.7Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Evan Smith

@esmith

4.8

Excellent pour. Smooth and creamy. The flavor wasn’t peak richness and complexity but overall top quality pint. I've been trying spots on people's "best Guinness in Manhattan" lists, and I think this is one of the two best (with Tara Mor).

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4Taste

Kevin H

@kh22

4.8

Arguably the best Guinness in Manhattan. Cheers.

• 4.7Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

Ndombele28

@ndombele28

4.3

Lovely pub. Very cozy. Good Guinness.

• 5Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 3.5Taste

Paul

@boldsession6020

4.8

Cozy bar, lovely staff, wonderful pint(s). Let me take home a glass!

• 5Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Sarah

@sarah

4.5

Deliciously creamy pint in a 20oz glass

• 4Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Darren

@darren

5.0

Been drinking Guinness at Graces for quite a while… you can’t go wrong here. Always consistent, always great.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

@office_guinness

@office_guinness

4.2

20 oz pour in pub branded tulip glass

• 4Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 4Taste

Sean O’Ceide

@sean-oceide

4.5

GRACES! Let me tell you now this is a GORGEOUS bar with an AMAZING snug if you get the chance to sit in it! Pints are honestly pure quality and are in my top 3 pints for sure! Beaten just barely by swift and the long hall, Graces is a MUST!

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste