Guinness Reviews - Grace's

Guinness & Black

4.9

A beautiful pub, attentive and well rounded staff behind the bar pouring a proper pint. Love the pint glasses.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

One of the best pints in NYC. Unfortunately I went during one of the hottest days of the year and the door was open so the Guinness didn’t taste as chilled as it should.

• 4.6Appearance
• 4.2Creaminess
• 4.4Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

good and creamy not the best glass

• 3.6Appearance
• 4.3Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 3.6Taste

This thing has a 5 head but the glass was clean as fuck. Temp was on the warm side (don’t bother me) but still had a nice mouthfeel. Bitterness upfront but chills to chocolate. Overall solid pint.

• 4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.3Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Head was a bit large but still a great pint

• 3.5Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.7Mouthfeel
• 4.9Taste

Nice Guinness. Head was a bit large. But had about 5 pints and they were all consistent.

• 4Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4.2Mouthfeel
• 4.2Taste

one of the best in the city frfr

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

If you’re good to Grace’s, Grace’s will be good to you. A great aul boozer. A great aul pint. Irish pub simplicity at its finest. A Guinness near its best marks in the city.

• 4Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Great creama, great setting.

• 4.4Appearance
• 4.6Creaminess
• 4.7Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Excellent pour. Smooth and creamy. The flavor wasn’t peak richness and complexity but overall top quality pint. I've been trying spots on people's "best Guinness in Manhattan" lists, and I think this is one of the two best (with Tara Mor).

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4Taste

Arguably the best Guinness in Manhattan. Cheers.

• 4.7Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.6Taste

Lovely pub. Very cozy. Good Guinness.

• 5Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 3.5Taste

Cozy bar, lovely staff, wonderful pint(s). Let me take home a glass!

• 5Appearance
• 4.5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

Sarah

4.5

Deliciously creamy pint in a 20oz glass

• 4Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 5Taste

Darren

4.8

Been drinking Guinness at Graces for quite a while… you can’t go wrong here. Always consistent, always great.

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 4.5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste

@office_guinness

4.2

20 oz pour in pub branded tulip glass

• 4Appearance
• 4Creaminess
• 4Mouthfeel
• 4Taste

GRACES! Let me tell you now this is a GORGEOUS bar with an AMAZING snug if you get the chance to sit in it! Pints are honestly pure quality and are in my top 3 pints for sure! Beaten just barely by swift and the long hall, Graces is a MUST!

• 5Appearance
• 5Creaminess
• 5Mouthfeel
• 4.5Taste