Guinness Reviews - Paddy Reilly's Music Bar
Read Guinness reviews with ratings and images for Paddy Reilly's Music Bar. Find out what people are saying about their Guinness experience.
Explore more on our world map
Locations
Search for a location to read its Guinness reviews.
@creamster
Best pint in manhattan
- 4Appearance
- 4.7Creaminess
- 4.7Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Fri August 14th, 2026
@jzirotti
Was there for an early post work drink. No music going on. Guinness pour looked OK but had a thin mouthfeel
- 4.5Appearance
- 3.6Creaminess
- 3.6Mouthfeel
- 3.6Taste
Added Tue April 7th, 2026
@classichead6186
good pint when it’s not very busy. if very busy, it’s rushed pour
- 4Appearance
- 3.8Creaminess
- 3.6Mouthfeel
- 3.7Taste
Added Mon March 16th, 2026
@thestoutfather
Concert and proper head
- 4.2Appearance
- 4.3Creaminess
- 4.3Mouthfeel
- 4.2Taste
Added Thu March 5th, 2026
@guinnesshound
Excellent pint
- 5Appearance
- 4.6Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Sun February 15th, 2026
@henrywalsh10
A lovely little pub
- 4.9Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Wed November 26th, 2025
@ndombele28
A lovely pub and a lovely pint.
- 4.8Appearance
- 4.5Creaminess
- 4.3Mouthfeel
- 4.4Taste
Updated Fri May 1st, 2026
@office_guinness
Class Pint - 20 OZ Gravity Glass
- 4.5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Updated Wed July 2nd, 2025
@calla
As good a pint as you’ll get outside Ireland.
- 5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Tue October 8th, 2024
@darren
A true Irish bar in NYC that serves a beautiful pint, like drinking ice cream!
- 5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Updated Sat June 6th, 2026