Guinness Reviews - The Long Hall Pub & Grocery
Read Guinness reviews with ratings and images for The Long Hall Pub & Grocery. Find out what people are saying about their Guinness experience.
Explore more on our world map
Locations
Search for a location to read its Guinness reviews.
@creamypint1701
Great pour! Fantastic pub! Brilliant!
- 4Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 4Mouthfeel
- 4Taste
Added Sat October 10th, 2026
@silkypour9371
08/09/2026
- 3.5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 3.5Mouthfeel
- 3.5Taste
Added Sat October 10th, 2026
@macmj86
First review and a worthwhile one! Searched out top Guinness stop for my 24 hour trip to NYC from Boston. The Long Hall was the first stop and ended up having 2. Bartender was from Waterford so I knew I was in for a great pour. Would stop in again!
- 4.4Appearance
- 4.6Creaminess
- 4.4Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Wed October 7th, 2026
@properpub2275
good pint, cute pub!
- 4Appearance
- 3.1Creaminess
- 4.2Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Sat September 19th, 2026
@stout_guy
It’s the best pint in the states for me. Rivals irish Guinness. Fantastic bar as well
- 5Appearance
- 4.8Creaminess
- 4.7Mouthfeel
- 4.7Taste
Added Tue September 15th, 2026
@boldstout3223
Quality pint highly recommend
- 4.7Appearance
- 4.3Creaminess
- 4.7Mouthfeel
- 4.7Taste
Added Sun September 6th, 2026
@baggo
This place is fantastic - you’d walk past it completely if you weren’t looking for it. Guinness is exceptional, would prefer a branded glass but the drink still speaks for itself. There should be a category for best Wi-fi name.
- 4.6Appearance
- 4.6Creaminess
- 4.6Mouthfeel
- 4.7Taste
Updated Wed June 10th, 2026
@willk
Bit of a high collar but one of the best pints in Manhattan.
- 4.4Appearance
- 4.5Creaminess
- 4.6Mouthfeel
- 4.7Taste
Added Sat May 23rd, 2026
@classichead6186
great pint of g
- 4.5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 4Mouthfeel
- 4Taste
Added Mon March 16th, 2026
@guinnesshound
Spot on f-ing awesome! Slightly high collar but super creamy deliciousness! Full imperial pints of course.
- 4.5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Wed February 18th, 2026
@ndombele28
Lovely staff. Lovely pint.
- 4.8Appearance
- 4.7Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.8Taste
Added Thu February 5th, 2026
@logan_fitzy
Immaculate pour
- 4.7Appearance
- 4.8Creaminess
- 4.8Mouthfeel
- 4.7Taste
Added Sat January 31st, 2026
@jcoconnor
Been here many times, consistently excellent pints. The bar staff are top notch.
- 4.8Appearance
- 4.9Creaminess
- 4.8Mouthfeel
- 4.9Taste
Added Sun January 18th, 2026
@gerry5pints
The Long Hall.... the most consistent pint in New York. I was here before and it was good, this time it was great! You will not be disappointed
- 4.4Appearance
- 4.7Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Thu November 6th, 2025
@calla
I’ve had many pints here, and they’re consistently great - I initially expected that a spot modeled so closely after a Dublin original would be inferior to the OG, but I’ve yet to find a flaw.
- 4.5Appearance
- 4Creaminess
- 3.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Sat July 20th, 2024
@jzirotti
So good I went back twice on my NYC trip! But they don't serve it in branded Guinness pint glasses.
- 4.5Appearance
- 4.5Creaminess
- 4.5Mouthfeel
- 4.5Taste
Added Tue June 4th, 2024
@sean-oceide
If you’re looking for a sure quality pint this is the place for you! Pints are so good you’ll forget you’re in New York and feel like you’re in Dublin. Never once had a bad pint here and confident I never will.
- 5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Added Tue June 4th, 2024
@darren
Absolute superb pint of Guinness. Pics are from different times!
- 5Appearance
- 5Creaminess
- 5Mouthfeel
- 5Taste
Updated Fri October 3rd, 2025